In the middle, or more aptly, on the fence, is the Care Commission.
It is a David and Goliath struggle over the issue of handwashing practices. The Secret Garden is an outdoor nursery with no running water and is being threatened by closure (News, 2 September). They are relying on the endeavours of parents and 'experts' to give them support, guidance and encouragement that they are right to take a stance for what they believe.
There is no argument - everyone agrees that handwashing is the best and most practical solution to keeping your hands clean - but no one is prepared to accept the responsibility of suggesting a suitable alternative when there is no soap and water for miles around. Nor will the authorities allow the nursery to conduct its own risk assessment of the potential dangers, even though all parents who send their children to the nursery are made aware of the hand hygiene policy and must sign a disclaimer.
I wonder why the Secret Garden is being pressured into adopting unworkable and even unsafe practices, or being forced to close? Is there more behind this issue at a time of Government cutbacks?
Whatever the reason, over the last few weeks the nursery has become more resolute in their cause. There is a steely reserve coming to the fore and they realise they are not alone. Many experts have offered support and advice free of charge and further support is coming in from many sources publicly and privately, who realise the implications are much wider and far reaching than those of a small nursery in the East Neuk of Fife. The outcome could affect all children engaging in outdoor activities, from simple play activities to Scout and Guide camps.
The nursery would welcome an e-mail of encouragement (enquiries@secretgardenoutdoor-nursery.co.uk) or a follow on twitter (@thesecretgardeners).